Comment Come meet to celebrate the fifth anniversary of Microsoft's Windows Insider program and its army of volunteer testers.
The Insider scheme appeared the day after Windows 10 was announced and was intended to provide users with preliminary versions of the biannually updated Microsoft operating system so that customers can check the new features in advance.
Announced by the then supreme Windows, Terry Myerson, the program was aimed directly at PC experts and IT professionals who, according to Myerson, had to be "comfortable using pre-launch software with variable quality."
As it happened, and thanks in part to the work of the Windows Insider program itself, those experts will eventually join common users as the quality of the Windows 10 versions suffered over the years.
Writing in 2014, veteran Windows observer Mary Jo Foley described the organizational changes that were implemented in Redmond
"Under the new structure," he wrote, "several Windows engineers, primarily dedicated testers, will no longer be needed" .
As it turned out, the Insiders would not only "shape Windows 10," as Myerson put it. They would become a critical part of the testing process. And things have not worked as the executive could have expected.
It all started very well. An optimistic publication of Brandon LeBlanc, which has stayed with the program, promised that Insiders would have an active role and could report through the Feedback application.
Four years later, ignoring that feedback, there was a disastrous launch of Windows 10 and accidental deletion of user data.
One of the first leaders of the Insider program, Gabe Aul, stayed with him for just under two years before handing over his beloved big red-build release button to his Microsoft partner Dona Sarkar, who has just arrived from One step through the HoloLens team.
Anatomy of the Insiders
As a reminder, the Windows Insider program consists of four test rings: a launch preview ring, supposedly the current branch and used just before updates to the world at large; a slow ring for a more stable preview code; a fast ring for more avant-garde constructions; and finally Skip Ahead, to take a look at the later version.
At least, that was the theory. The rings have become a little blurry over the years due to multiple constructions with different levels of functionality.
Hell, earlier this year, each ring was accidentally hit with Windows 10. next year
To celebrate the five years of the Windows Insider program, we have compiled a useful list of the team's five greatest hits.
5. Communication failures
Compared to large fragments of the "new" Microsoft, the Windows team seems to be still in a world where customers should be grateful for any information. Compare and contrast with, for example, the efforts of the Windows subsystem for the Linux gang.
Things reached a critical point this year with the mystery of 19H2. What would be in it? Where was it? When would the insiders see it? The entire team told its users that there would be more "by the end of spring" before stupidly stating that spring would end every time Microsoft said it would.
4. Ninja cats and taco hats
While the quality of Windows 10 began to get a little worse, the Windows Insider program seemed more obsessed with external activities, such as extension work and pets.
While extension efforts were commendable, customers faced modified patches and unstable updates.
Users could have been forgiven for wishing that similar amounts of energy were spent on testing the code and correcting errors.
3. Springwatch and random tests
The first update of Windows 10 features of 2018 suffered a mysterious delay until Microsoft finally admitted that the thing was too faulty to launch.
While that bullet was dodged, the Insider team also began a journey that would leave their army of unpaid testers unable to really test the technology for which they had signed up thanks to an electronic roll of the dice.
2. The October 2018 update
Everything that was wrong with the Windows Insider program was demonstrated last year with the Windows 10 October 2018 update. The thing actually deleted your data if not was lucky.
Things were so catastrophically bad that Microsoft was forced to withdraw the update a few days after launch. A "small change" in the approach meant that the launch preview ring was omitted, something LeBlanc briefly explained to concerned users.
It is not irrelevant. We have just made a small change in our approach. 1809 will go to RP today and it will be essential to help start the service. Slow was useful to help identify any show that stopped mistakes this time.
– Brandon LeBlanc (@brandonleblanc) October 2, 2018
1. Windows 10
Perhaps the greatest achievement of the Windows Insider program was to make Windows 10 "officially a shit show," according to our own Andrew Orlowski. Just when Microsoft was desperately trying to persuade users to migrate from Windows 7.
The Reg along with other observers, he suggested that Microsoft should really bring back those redundant testers, reuse the Insider program as something purely for enthusiasts and, for God's sake, slow down.
As the Windows Insider program celebrates its fifth birthday, this last point seems to have been taken into account.
The next update, 19H2, which will be released in October, will be little more than an accelerated patch, which means that 2019 will only have seen an important release, in the form of the relatively stable update of May 2019.
However, the team has not yet confirmed if this is the way things will be from now on.
And so, if we could give the Windows Insider program a gift for its fifth birthday, it would be the ability to communicate.
And maybe reduce the problem. ®
What follows after Netezza?